Reviewdle 28 – Music documentaries from either end of the spectrum

Caveat:  Just because I’m giving a rockumentary a bad review and a classical music documentary a good review, please don’t think I’m a music snob.  Yes, I enjoy and get along to a fair whack of classical music, but I’m also a fan of the rock end of the radio dial too.  Right, now on with it…

It Might Get Loud  

What happens when documentary director Davis Guggenheim (An Inconvenient Truth) get the World’s Greatest Guitarists (for these purposes Jimmy Page, The Edge and Jack White) into a room together for a one-day-only, no-holds-barred, anything-goes meeting?  They nerd out about guitars, that’s what.  I seemed to enjoy the running time well enough (although it could definitely have been shorter) but on reflection can’t really pinpoint much of merit in the film.  It lacks direction and the information and interviews lack context, so it feels rather more like a fan film, made for those among us who already know everything about these guys and the history of guitar rock (not me), than those who like documentaries about things they don’t know much about and are seeking to be entertained and educated (definitely me).  Some bits focusing on creative processes (especially The Edge’s) were fascinating, but not more so than some other bits were irritating or contrived (Jack White teaching his 9 year old self how to fight with music?  Really?).  If you’re a fan of any or all of these guitarists then no doubt you’ll find something to interest you.  If not, listen to an album instead.

In Search of Beethoven  

Beethoven’s piano works to me had always seemed so show-offy.  In Search of Beethoven has explained to me that they seem arrogant because they ARE arrogant.  And no wonder given that he was not only a genius performer (with HUGE hands) but, creatively and musically, terrifically ambitious.  TV and feature documentary film-maker Phil Grabsky (The Boy who Plays on the Buddhas of Bamiyan) has made the second in a presumably ongoing series about great classical composers.  Although he’s starting with the obvious (first Mozart and now Beethoven) his approach is fresh and his style is energetic.  Not only is the music spectacular, but Beethoven’s story and character are so fascinating.  There is a little too much “he was such a dark person, but, the interesting thing, you see, is that his music is so filled with hope” and not enough notation about the names, chronology and musicians of the 60-odd pieces that were performed live for the film.  The documentary focuses more on Beethoven’s blockbuster pieces (for example, the 5th (da da da dummmmm) and 9th (ode to joy) symphonies) without shining a light on his 100-odd other works, but the music that is covered is so good that it’s a slight complaint.  Aside from being enormously entertaining, I learned a lot from this film (including an understanding and new appreciation of Beethoven’s piano works) and you can’t you can’t ask more from a documentary than that.

– Jen

^ 2 Comments...

  1. Rick Boyer

    I just stopped by your blog and thought I would say hello. I like your site design. Looking forward to reading more down the road.

  2. Sockpuppet

    Hey there Rick! Thanks for saying hi (and nice things about Trev’s site design). I’m glad what you saw made you want to come back. Anytime, day or night, we’re always here and you’re always welcome.

    – Jen